The essentials of ICS security
The security of our critical infrastructure has never been more vital. At the heart of this concern lies a crucial question: What is ICS security? Industrial Control System (ICS) security is the frontline defense protecting the systems that manage our power grids, water treatment facilities, manufacturing plants, and other essential industrial processes. As cyber threats evolve and target these critical systems with growing sophistication, understanding ICS security has become paramount for businesses, governments, and security professionals alike.
Whether you’re a seasoned professional in the industrial sector or new to the world of operational technology, this article will provide valuable insights into safeguarding the backbone of our modern industrial landscape. Join us as we delve into the intricacies of ICS security and discover why it’s a critical component in ensuring the safety, reliability, and resilience of our industrial infrastructure.
Subscribe to our newsletter to stay in the loop with the latest OT cyber security best practices.
Verve’s Biweekly Newsletter
Subscribe to stay in the loop with the latest OT cyber security best practices.
Fill out form below
What is an Industrial Control System?
Industrial Control Systems (ICS) are the backbone of modern industrial operations, serving as the nervous system for critical infrastructure and manufacturing processes. These systems encompass a wide range of technologies and equipment designed to monitor, control, and automate industrial processes across various sectors.
What is ICS security?
ICS security, short for Industrial Control System security, is a specialized branch of cybersecurity that protects the critical systems that control and monitor industrial processes. Also known as Operational Technology (OT) security, it safeguards a wide range of industrial infrastructure including:
- Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) Systems that monitor and control processes across geographically dispersed locations, often in industries like power generation, water treatment, and oil and gas.
- Programmable Logic Controllers (PLCs) that automate specific tasks within an industrial process, such as controlling assembly lines or robotic arms.
- Distributed Control Systems (DCS) that manage complex industrial processes across interconnected controllers and sensors commonly found in refineries, chemical plants, and manufacturing facilities.
- Human-Machine Interfaces (HMIs) that interact with and control industrial processes.
Evolution in ICS Security
Traditionally, ICS operated in isolated environments, separate from corporate IT networks. However, the drive for efficiency and real-time data access has led to increased connectivity between ICS and IT networks. This convergence, often referred to as IT/OT integration, has brought significant benefits but also introduced new cybersecurity challenges.
The Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) is further transforming ICS landscapes, enabling smart factories and predictive maintenance but also expanding the potential attack surface for cyber threats.
Key Components of ICS Security Include:
- Asset Inventory: Maintaining a comprehensive list of all devices and systems within the ICS environment.
- Vulnerability Management: Identifying, assessing, and mitigating vulnerabilities in ICS components.
- Network Segmentation: Isolating critical systems from less secure networks.
- Endpoint Protection: Securing individual devices within the ICS network.
- Patch Management: Safely updating software and firmware to address known vulnerabilities.
ICS security encompasses a range of practices and technologies designed to defend these systems from cyber threats to ensure industrial operations’ integrity, availability, and safety. This doesn’t only protect the digital systems themselves but also the physical infrastructure they control.
Industries Relying on ICS Security
- Energy and Utilities (power generation, water treatment)
- Manufacturing (automotive, food and beverage, pharmaceuticals)
- Transportation (railways, air traffic control)
- Oil and Gas (refineries, pipelines)
- Chemical Processing
- Mining and Metals
Importance of ICS Security
Given the critical nature of the processes controlled by ICS, ensuring their security is paramount. A breach in an ICS could lead to:
- Production stoppages
- Equipment damage
- Environmental disasters
- Public safety risks
- Significant financial losses
Understanding the unique characteristics and requirements of Industrial Control Systems is crucial for developing effective ICS security strategies. As these systems become more connected and digitally dependent, the need for robust, specialized security measures becomes increasingly critical.
Examples of Real-World ICS Security Threats and Attacks
There were over 48,000 exposed ICS services in the US in 2024. An example of an ICS security attack over the last year is with the Cyber Army of Russia Reborn (CARR). This nation-state organization gained unauthorized access via Telegram, tampered with the HMIs, and overflowed water storage tanks in Muleshoe, Texas. Causing downtime and damage.
Why Do We Need ICS Security?
The need for robust ICS security has never been more critical. As industrial systems become increasingly connected to corporate networks and the internet, they’ve become attractive targets for cybercriminals and state-sponsored threat actors. Consider these alarming statistics:
- According to the U.S. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), there was a 30% increase in cyber incidents targeting critical infrastructure sectors in 2023 compared to the previous year.
- The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) reported that vulnerabilities in Industrial Control Systems increased by 44% in 2020.
- A report from the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) found that the number of cybersecurity incidents reported by federal agencies increased by more than 1,300 percent from 2006 to 2015.
- The World Economic Forum’s Global Risks Report 2021 ranks cyberattacks on critical infrastructure as the 5th highest risk by likelihood and 8th by impact.
Potential Consequences of ICS Breaches
The impact of a successful attack on an ICS can be severe and far-reaching:
- Safety Risks: In 2021, a hacker attempted to poison the water supply in Oldsmar, Florida, by increasing the levels of sodium hydroxide in the water treatment system. While this attempt was thwarted, it highlights the potential for physical harm to the public.
- Economic Losses: The 2017 NotPetya attack, which affected numerous companies including shipping giant Maersk, resulted in estimated global damages of $10 billion.
- Environmental Damage: In 2000, a disgruntled former employee hacked into the control systems of a sewage treatment plant in Maroochy Shire, Australia, causing millions of liters of raw sewage to spill into local parks and rivers.
- National Security Threats: The 2015 attack on Ukraine’s power grid, attributed to Russian hackers, left 230,000 people without electricity for up to six hours, demonstrating the potential for ICS attacks to disrupt critical national infrastructure.
- Reputational Damage: In 2014, a German steel mill suffered significant damage when a cyber-attack prevented the proper shut down of a blast furnace. Beyond the immediate physical and financial impact, such incidents can severely damage a company’s reputation and customer trust.
These examples underscore the critical need for robust ICS security measures. As industrial systems become more interconnected and digitally dependent, the potential consequences of breaches grow more severe, making ICS security an imperative for organizations across all industrial sectors.
Financial Impact of Breaches in ICS Security
The Cyber Threat Snapshot from the Committee of Homeland Security revealed that the average cost of a data breach in the US was $9.36 million—nearly double the global average.
Downtime is critical for businesses but can vary by industry. Manufacturing spaces could be upwards of $260,000. Here are three key ways you can calculate downtime based on industry:
- Manufacturing downtime = (Hourly labor cost + hourly overhead cost + hourly production cost) x downtime duration
- Wastewater treatment downtime = (Regulatory fines + environmental cleanup costs + labor costs + equipment repair/replacement + potential public health costs)
- Energy downtime = (Lost electricity sales + equipment repair/replacement + labor costs + regulatory fines + potential safety/environment costs)
Demonstrating ROI of Security Investments
While security is an investment, there are a few trackable metrics that can help you demonstrate ROI to your stakeholders:
- Reduction in Security Incidents: Monitor the number of successful and attempted cyberattacks, malware infections, and unauthorized access attempts.
- Improved Uptime: Track the percentage of uptime for critical systems and measure the reduction in unplanned downtime.
- Compliance with Regulations: Document compliance with industry standards and regulations to avoid fines and demonstrate due diligence.
- Risk Reduction: While difficult to quantify directly, emphasize the value of reducing the likelihood and impact of potential breaches. Use risk assessment frameworks to demonstrate the decrease in risk exposure.
How to Address Fear of Disrupting Critical Processes
Security doesn’t have to mean downtime. There are a few ways to implement security measures strategically to minimize disruption:
- Roll out security controls in phases based on priority from your OT security team
- Use virtual patching or compensating controls to address vulnerabilities without taking systems offline.
- Divide the network into isolated segments to limit the impact of the breach
- Implement backup systems to take over if one system needs to go offline
- Align your testing and update with the operations teams so there is no conflict with required uptime
How Does ICS Security Differ from IT Security?
Your ICS is the backbone of your company’s operations. They manage everything from power grids to manufacturing lines—and their smooth operation directly impacts your bottom line. While IT security focuses on data and networks, ICS security focuses on securing the physical processes that the systems control.
Unique Challenges of ICS Devices ICS environments often include legacy systems and specialized devices that pose unique security challenges:
- Many ICS devices run outdated operating systems (e.g., Windows XP) that no longer receive security updates.
- Embedded systems like PLCs (Programmable Logic Controllers) and RTUs (Remote Terminal Units) often lack built-in security features.
- ICS components typically have long life cycles (15-20 years), making frequent updates or replacements impractical.
Differing Risk Priorities
The risk priorities in ICS and IT environments are fundamentally different:
- IT Security prioritizes: 1) Confidentiality, 2) Integrity, 3) Availability
- ICS Security prioritizes: 1) Safety, 2) Availability, 3) Integrity, 4) Confidentiality This difference stems from the potential physical consequences of ICS breaches, which can include equipment damage, environmental disasters, or even loss of life.
Incident Detection and Response Detecting and responding to security incidents in ICS environments requires a different approach:
- ICS networks often have predictable traffic patterns, making anomaly detection more straightforward but requiring specialized knowledge to interpret.
- Response actions in ICS must be carefully planned to avoid disrupting critical processes. Unlike IT systems, you can’t simply shut down an ICS component if a threat is detected.
Requirement for Specialized Knowledge Effective ICS security requires a unique skill set:
- Deep understanding of industrial processes and control systems
- Knowledge of specialized protocols (e.g., Modbus, DNP3, OPC)
- Familiarity with regulatory requirements specific to industrial sectors (e.g., NERC CIP for power utilities)
How does ICS security differ from IT security?
While ICS security and IT security share some common goals, they differ significantly in their approaches, priorities, and challenges. Understanding these differences is crucial for effectively protecting industrial control systems.
Unique Challenges of ICS Devices ICS environments often include legacy systems and specialized devices that pose unique security challenges:
- Many ICS devices run outdated operating systems (e.g., Windows XP) that no longer receive security updates.
- Embedded systems like PLCs (Programmable Logic Controllers) and RTUs (Remote Terminal Units) often lack built-in security features.
- ICS components typically have long lifecycles (15-20 years), making frequent updates or replacements impractical.
Differing risk priorities
The risk priorities in ICS and IT environments are fundamentally different:
- IT Security prioritizes: 1) Confidentiality, 2) Integrity, 3) Availability
- ICS Security prioritizes: 1) Safety, 2) Availability, 3) Integrity, 4) Confidentiality This difference stems from the potential physical consequences of ICS breaches, which can include equipment damage, environmental disasters, or even loss of life.
Incident Detection and Response Detecting and responding to security incidents in ICS environments requires a different approach:
- ICS networks often have predictable traffic patterns, making anomaly detection more straightforward but requiring specialized knowledge to interpret.
- Response actions in ICS must be carefully planned to avoid disrupting critical processes. Unlike IT systems, you can’t simply shut down an ICS component if a threat is detected.
Requirement for Specialized Knowledge Effective ICS security requires a unique skill set:
- Deep understanding of industrial processes and control systems
- Knowledge of specialized protocols (e.g., Modbus, DNP3, OPC)
- Familiarity with regulatory requirements specific to industrial sectors (e.g., NERC CIP for power utilities)
This table provides a clear, side-by-side comparison of key differences between IT and ICS security. When creating the actual blog post, you might consider turning this into an infographic for better visual appeal and easier comprehension.
By understanding these fundamental differences, organizations can develop more effective strategies for securing their industrial control systems, recognizing that a one-size-fits-all approach borrowed from IT security is insufficient for the unique challenges of the ICS environment.
How Do We Achieve ICS Security?
Securing Industrial Control Systems requires a comprehensive, strategic approach that addresses the unique challenges of the OT environment while leveraging best practices from IT security. Here’s how organizations can effectively achieve ICS security:
Setting Goals and Designing a Security Program
- Assess Current State: Conduct a thorough inventory of all ICS assets and evaluate existing security measures.
- Define Objectives: Set clear, measurable security goals aligned with industry standards (e.g., NIST Cybersecurity Framework, IEC 62443).
- Develop Policies and Procedures: Create comprehensive security policies tailored to your ICS environment.
- Implement Controls: Deploy technical, administrative, and physical controls to protect your ICS assets.
- Continuous Monitoring and Improvement: Regularly assess and update your security program to address emerging threats.
Watch on Demand:
How to Build a Robust OT Cybersecurity Program
The rise of ransomware attacks and stricter regulations (like the 2021 TSA guidelines) demand a proactive approach to securing critical infrastructure. This session with John Livingston will equip you to achieve compliance with OT regulations like vulnerability management, mitigate endpoint risks with practical controls for OT environments, and bridge the gap between IT security and OT needs. Learn how to effectively defend your industrial systems in today’s evolving threat landscape.
Integrating IT and OT for a Unified Security Approach
- Bridge the Knowledge Gap: Facilitate knowledge sharing between IT and OT teams to build mutual understanding.
- Establish Joint Governance: Create a cross-functional team to oversee ICS security initiatives.
- Develop Integrated Processes: Align IT and OT security processes while respecting the unique requirements of each domain.
- Implement Compatible Technologies: Choose security solutions that can operate effectively in both IT and OT environments.
- Foster a Unified Security Culture: Promote a security-aware culture that spans both IT and OT personnel.
Learn More About the Difference Between IT and OT
Explore the complexities of IT vs OT, their unique roles, integration challenges, and strategic approaches for effective convergence.
Read the BlogChoosing a Security Platform Over Individual Tools
Adopting an integrated security platform offers several advantages over implementing multiple point solutions:
- Comprehensive Visibility: A unified platform provides a holistic view of your entire ICS environment.
- Streamlined Management: Centralized management reduces complexity and improves efficiency.
- Consistent Policy Enforcement: Ensure uniform security policies across your ICS landscape.
- Improved Incident Response: Correlate data from multiple sources for faster, more effective threat detection and response.
- Cost-Effective: Reduce total cost of ownership compared to maintaining multiple disparate tools.
- Scalability: Easily expand security coverage as your ICS environment grows or evolves.
Learn more about Verve's Unified Solution
Don't let fragmented security tools leave gaps in your defenses. Discover how Verve's unified approach can enhance your ICS security posture while reducing complexity and costs.
Learn MoreICS Security Framework
This framework provides a visual representation of how various security components work together to create a robust ICS security program.
By following these strategies and implementing a comprehensive security platform, organizations can significantly enhance their ICS security posture. Remember, achieving ICS security is an ongoing process that requires continuous attention, updates, and improvements to stay ahead of evolving threats and changing industrial landscapes.
The Critical Role of ICS Security in Today’s Connected World
Industrial Control System (ICS) security is not just a technical necessity—it’s a critical component of operational resilience and public safety in our increasingly connected world. As we’ve explored, ICS security:
- Protects the critical systems that control and monitor industrial processes across various sectors, from energy and utilities to manufacturing and transportation.
- Differs significantly from traditional IT security, with unique challenges stemming from legacy systems, specialized devices, and the prioritization of safety and availability.
- Requires a comprehensive approach that integrates asset management, vulnerability assessment, network segmentation, and continuous monitoring.
- Demands collaboration between IT and OT teams to create a unified security strategy that addresses the complexities of modern industrial environments.
- Plays a crucial role in safeguarding against cyber threats that could lead to production stoppages, equipment damage, environmental disasters, or even public safety risks.
Navigating ICS Security in the Age of IoT and Industry 4.0
While Industry 4.0 is transforming industrial operations, it also introduces new security challenges. Connecting more systems and devices to the network expands the attack surface and makes ICS environments more vulnerable to cyberthreats.
As industrial systems become more interconnected and digitally dependent, the importance of robust ICS security measures cannot be overstated. It’s not just about protecting data—it’s about protecting data integrity, preventing unauthorized access, and ensuring the continued operation of the critical infrastructure that underpins our society and economy.
How to Fortify Your Industrial Control Systems Now
The landscape of ICS security is complex and ever-evolving, but you don’t have to navigate it alone. Take the first step towards strengthening your industrial cybersecurity posture:
- Assess Your Current State: Conduct a thorough inventory of your ICS assets and evaluate your existing security measures. Identify any gaps or vulnerabilities in your current approach.
- Educate Your Team: Ensure that both your IT and OT personnel understand the unique challenges and importance of ICS security. Consider investing in specialized training programs.
- Develop a Roadmap: Create a comprehensive plan for enhancing your ICS security, including short-term wins and long-term strategic goals.
- Seek Expert Guidance: ICS security requires specialized knowledge and experience. Don’t hesitate to consult with professionals who can provide tailored advice and solutions for your specific industrial environment.
- Explore Unified Solutions: Consider how an integrated security platform could streamline your efforts and provide comprehensive protection across your ICS landscape.
Don’t wait for a security incident to highlight vulnerabilities in your ICS environment. Act now to safeguard your industrial operations and ensure a resilient, secure future for your organization.
